Blog

  • YFZ – CPS Press Conference

    YFZ – CPS Press Conference

    Eldorado – Marleigh Meisner, spokesperson for the Texas Child Protective Services, confirms at a press conference that the CPS has removed 183 people, 137 of them children, from the YFZ “Yearning for Zion” FLDS polygamous compound. The press conference took place at the Eldorado High School, Saturday, April 5, 2008.
    This is the first CPS press conference. It was held at the Eldorado High School and helmed by CPS spokesperson Marleigh Meisner. At this point the media on-site was a very small group. Meisner told us that 183 people had been removed from the YFZ Ranch, 137 of them children. I remember that seemed like a big number, though it would soon be eclipsed.
  • Raid at YFZ

    Raid at YFZ

    I didn’t expect to be in Texas today. But then I woke up and saw the news, that law enforcement had gone into the secretive FLDS compound just outside Eldorado, Texas, to investigate allegations of child abuse among the polygamous community. We knew we had to go, even if there was a chance that it would all be over by the time we got there. It took us all day to get to Eldorado. Eleven hours of TSA, delayed flights, several broken carry-on luggage rules, missed connecting flights, a missing bag containing about $20,000 worth of equipment (it turned up), a lame KFC dinner eaten while driving, you name it. What a joy travel is in the “modern” age. Along the way we kept getting more bits of information about what was happening. Some substantiated, some rumor, some speculation, all of it fascinating. It was soon verified that children were being removed from the “Yearning for Zion” compound by law enforcement. Now we had a story. A historic event, even. The Short Creek raid in 1953 was a flashpoint in the history of polygamy. Women and children were separated from their husbands and fathers by the state of Arizona. And now, fifty-five years later we see another raid. As of tonight, there is no telling where events will lead. The 1953 raid was a public relations disaster for the Arizona government, and after two years nearly every family was reunited. I can’t tell you what will happen here in Texas. I can’t tell you who is right or who is wrong. I can only show you what I saw tonight when we drove into town:
    4.04.2008 0467.jpg
    These FLDS children were arriving at the First Baptist Church in Eldorado, Texas, a temporary shelter for them as the investigation/raid continues. A few notes about the photo, which I feel captures an historic moment in the FLDS story. First, there had to be some sensitivity in the taking of the photograph. Luckily, I brought along a 50/1.4 lens so that I wouldn’t need to use flash. Popping a flash at children who were just taken from their parents and homes would not have been compassionate. Like a good backpacker, I wanted to leave a minimal footprint. So I shot available light, something like 1/30th at f1.4 at ISO 800. Maybe when I’m actually awak I’ll actually tone and sharpen it for you, but it’s been a long day. Some of the volunteers at the church clearly didn’t want me taking photographs. They were good people looking out for the FLDS, who are very private people. I can understand their feelings. But this is an important story. I try to work with the same compassion they were feeling for the children. Once we had the photo, we left. In the morning we’ll go back and hopefully it will be more obvious that while we’re serious journalists, we’re not “THE MEDIA.”
  • YFZ – First Baptist Church

    YFZ – First Baptist Church

    Eldorado – FLDS children who were removed from the YFZ Ranch are brought to the First Baptist Church, Friday April 4, 2008
    Eldorado – FLDS children who were removed from the YFZ Ranch are brought to the First Baptist Church, Friday April 4, 2008 Eldorado – Volunteers (who did not want to be photographed) unload food at the First Baptist Church for FLDS children who were removed from the YFZ Ranch Friday April 4, 2008
  • YFZ Revisited – April 4, 2008

    YFZ Revisited – April 4, 2008

    Originally published November 7, 2008. Just minutes after I photographed the food I noticed that a bus had pulled up down the street. Even in the dark I could see the heads of children on the bus.
    4.04.2008 0462.jpg
    It was really dark, but I had a fast 50/1.4 lens that would let me shoot without flash. I quickly snapped the photo above as a test frame to check my exposure. The women and children walked to the First Baptist Church and I clicked off twenty quick frames in the dark.
    4.04.2008 0467.jpg
    That photo ended up being used all over the place. Looking through all twenty frames, I see that some of the children noticed me and others appeared not to. Here are more frames, some of which have never been published before:
    4.04.2008 0471.jpg
    4.04.2008 0475.jpg
    4.04.2008 0479.jpg
    4.04.2008 0481.jpg
    I wrote this about the technical aspect of shooting the photo on the blog back in April:
    A few notes about the photo, which I feel captures an historic moment in the FLDS story. First, there had to be some sensitivity in the taking of the photograph. Luckily, I brought along a 50/1.4 lens so that I wouldn’t need to use flash. Popping a flash at children who were just taken from their parents and homes would not have been compassionate. Like a good backpacker, I wanted to leave a minimal footprint. So I shot available light, something like 1/30th at f1.4 at ISO 800. Maybe when I’m actually awake I’ll actually tone and sharpen it for you, but it’s been a long day.
    Back then I also wrote a bit about how the volunteers (and knowing more now, CPS) didn’t want me there and definitely didn’t want any photographs taken. But we were standing on a public sidewalk so there was little they could do. Immediately after shooting this sequence I walked across the street to the car and began sending photos back to the office, just ahead of deadline. Then I went back to look for more photo possibilities. You can see how the doors to this room of the church have vertical slit windows. I could see the occasional FLDS woman through these windows but before I got a shot off a short-haired woman with light-colored pants (she’s in the last two photos above) approached me with several other locals. One was the mayor of Eldorado. They were very angry at my presence. The mayor asked who I was and what I was doing there. I told him. The woman asked if I had taken any photos. I said yes. Around this point an officer led me off to the side away from the group and told me that while he knew I had every right to photograph from the sidewalk, these locals were really pissed off that I was there and if I stayed much longer, he wouldn’t be able to guarantee my safety. We evaluated the situation and decided to leave, knowing we had the shot (which would run across the entire width of the next day’s front page) and knowing we would be back early in the morning. I wrote this back then about us leaving:
    Some of the volunteers at the church clearly didn’t want me taking photographs. They were good people looking out for the FLDS, who are very private people. I can understand their feelings. But this is an important story. I try to work with the same compassion they were feeling for the children. Once we had the photo, we left. In the morning we’ll go back and hopefully it will be more obvious that while we’re serious journalists, we’re not “THE MEDIA.”
    My perception has changed substantially from what I wrote then. While there were privacy expectations (as there would be in any child-protective action), the story of the YFZ Raid was heavily media-managed from the start. In some cases they were following official policy and/or state law, but Texas officials would limit access to the photography of this story nearly every step of the way.
  • Hser Ner Moo goes missing

    Hser Ner Moo goes missing

    UPDATE: Terribly sad ending to this story. Just after I posted this, police discovered Hser’s body in a neighbor’s apartment. I hardly expected my first day back from vacation to be anything like this. But when I read the news early Tuesday morning that a 7-year-old girl had gone missing, I knew this would be far from a regular day. Hser Nay Moo was last seen Monday afternoon, and today the search cranked into high gear. Another photographer covered the search for Hser and I was paired up with a reporter working on the Burmese community angle. While I waited for her to set things up over the phone I drove to the apartment complex where Hser and her family had lived for several months after fleeing unrest in Burma. There were TV trucks all along the street and a police helicopter circling the place. I walked in past two South Salt Lake police officers and into the complex. TV reporters were interviewing various residents of the complex. One broadcaster was asking a group of young children something like, “So are you scared now that this has happened?” I walked around a corner and saw a trio of tripods aiming at what must be the family’s apartment. Kids were peeking out of the apartment next door, staring at the cameras and waving to the police officer stationed in the parking lot. I wandered over just as someone came out of the apartment and said that a family member would be coming out to talk. Any second now. A quick call to the newsroom summoned a reporter, pronto. A short while later Cartoon Wah, the girl’s father, came out to talk. No other print media were there for this grieving father’s emotional display. Shortly after the police closed off the complex to everyone but residents, including media. Let’s hope this little girl returns home safe and sound.